“People who believe in God are ignorant and superstitious. Intelligent, educated people do not believe in God.” Perhaps you have read or heard such nonsense spouted by the so-called “new atheists.” This is an ignorant and arrogant falsehood. From time to time in this blog, I will feature quotations from highly respected scientists (many Nobel Prize winners) who are solid theists. Hopefully, such information will put to rest such misinformed arguments among open-minded readers.
Consider Nobel Prize winner Sir John Eccles. Sir John was an Aussie, born in Melbourne in 1903 and died in 1997. More information can be found in Wickipedia and at Nobelprize.org.
Science and religion are very much alike. Both are imaginative and creative aspects of the human mind. The appearance of conflict is a result of ignorance.
We come to exist through a divine act. That divine guidance is a theme throughout our life; at our death the brain goes, but that divine guidance and love continues. Each of us is a unique, conscious being, a divine creation. It is the religious view. It is the only view consistent with all the evidence.
There has been a regrettable tendency of many scientists to claim that science is so powerful and all pervasive that in the not too distant future it will provide an explanation in principle for all phenomena in the world of nature, including man, even of human consciousness in all of its manifestations. [Karl] Popper has labeled this claim as promissory materialism, which is extravagant and unfulfillable.
Yet on account of the high regard for science, it has great persuasive power with the intelligent laity because it is advocated by the great mass of scientists who have not critically evaluated the dangers of this false and arrogant claim.
I regard this theory as being without foundation. The more we discover scientifically about the brain, the more clearly do we distinguish between the brain events and the mental phenomena, and the more wonderful do the mental phenomena become. Promissory materialism is simply a superstition held by dogmatic materialists. It has all the features of a Messianic prophecy, with the promise of a future freed of all problems—a kind of Nirvana for our unfortunate successors.
We have to recognize that we are spiritual beings with souls existing in a spiritual world as well as material beings with bodies and brains existing in a material world.
The amazing success of the theory of evolution has protected it from significant critical evaluation in recent times. However, it fails in a most important respect. It cannot account for the existence of each one of us as unique, self-conscious beings.
Thanks to John Clayton and Does God Exist? Quotes were downloaded from http://www.doesgodexist.org/MayJun10/Eccles-Nobel.html, 18 July 2010
Filed under Apologetics, Atheism/Theism, Bigotry, Culture Wars, Faith, Ignorance, Intelligence, Philosophy, Quotations, Religion, Science, Supernatural, Theism, Thinking
“The bigotry of the nonbeliever is for me nearly as funny as the bigotry of the believer.”
— Albert Einstein 
Quotes from two atheists demonstrate an unattractive and arrogant elitism for which there is no credible reason. Guy P. Harrison said, “…atheism is not a conscious act of turning away from all gods. It is simply the final destination for those who think.” Ernest Hemingway concurred, “All thinking men are atheists.” Many similar quotes from so-called “new atheists,” echo these sentiments. Such statements are deluded, egocentric and, with all due respect, stupid. I define “stupid” as willful ignorance. I suppose we have all been stupid from time to time, but such statements qualify since they are made in spite of facts to the contrary.
Perhaps a teeny history lesson is needed here. Religious thinkers have existed in every age. Historically, they laid the foundations for today’s science and philosophy and founded nations. Can “thinkers” be “believers?” Below, I provide a list of such people who, in the opinion of most, are “thinkers.” For the sake of brevity, I have confined my list to the 20th and 21st Centuries. These are men and women who, though some may not believe in a “personal God” have acknowledged a “higher power.” To this power they attribute some role in the design and creation of the universe and the origin of life.
R. Buckminster Fuller
Wernher Von Braun
C. S. Lewis
Edwin “Buzz” Aldrin, Jr.
G. K. Chesterton
William Lane Craig
Martin Luther King, Jr.
This is certainly not an exhaustive list. But the question remains: were these men and women thinkers or not? Of course, a similar list could be compiled for atheist thinkers. But, then again, I would not be so blind and bold to say otherwise. It is estimated that 40% of working scientists are believers. Yes, they are a minority, but a large one. But here’s the pertinent query: can they do science without thinking? I think not.
Will this tiny article put a stop to such foolishness? Not if those who make such inane statements continue to ignore the facts. Ironic, isn’t it? Those who disparage theists for believing in God without evidence ignore ample, overwhelming evidence. Off the cuff, I can only think of five reasons for such statements:
- They can’t handle the inconvenient truth.
- They have invented their own exclusive standards and definitions for “thinkers.”
- They arbitrarily decide that theists can get lucky sometimes but can’t really think.
- They believe they have a corner on intelligence.
- They need to get out more.
Makes you think, doesn’t it?
You can read about more theist thinkers here and here.
Goldman, Robert N., Einstein’s God—Albert Einstein’s Quest as a Scientist and as a Jew to Replace a Forsaken God
(Joyce Aronson Inc.; Northvale, New Jersy; 1997).
Filed under Apologetics, Atheism/Theism, Bigotry, Culture Wars, Faith, Hypocrisy, Ignorance, Intelligence, Mind, Persuasion, Philosophy, Religion, Ridicule, Science, Theism, Thinking